Disable Preloader

CaseLaw

Confidence Ins. Ltd V. Trustees of O.S.C.E. (1999) CLR 2(I) (CA)

Brief

  • Grounds of appeal
  • Arbitration clause
  • Stay of proceedings pending appeal
  • Facts admitted in pleading
  • Waiver

Facts

The respondents filed an action against the appellant at the High Court claiming a total sum of N3,500,000.000 in connection with a fund administration scheme. Both parties exchanged pleadings after appellant, as 2nd defendant, had entered an unqualified or unconditional appearance.

In its statement of defence. The appellant averred that the respondent's action was premature as the respondents were yet to utilize and or exhaust the arbitration provision in the trust deed in the case. The said arbitration clause contained in paragraph 19 of the trust deed read:

  • "All differences arising in relation to the fund or any matter or things connected therewith shall be referred to a single arbitrator or two arbitrators. One to be appointed by each party or their umpire in accordance with the Arbitration Laws of the Federation currently in force, and unless or until an award has been made, no action or other legal proceedings shall be commenced in respect of any matter in dispute."

By a motion on notice, the respondents prayed the trial court to enter judgment in their favour on an admission of sums of N1,411.019.43 as set out in the appellant's pleading. The trial court entered judgment in favour of the respondents against the appellant only in respect of the sum duly admitted by the appellant.

Issues

Whether the arbitration clause in the trust deed was capable of ousting the...

Read More