Disable Preloader

CaseLaw

City Eng. (Nig) Ltd V. NAA (1999) CLR 11(g) (SC)

Brief

  • Arbitration (Appointment of & condition precedent to)
  • Arbitration (Reference to & condition precedent to)
  • Arbitration (Reference to & Inherent jurisdiction of court)
  • Technicalities (Attitude of court to)
  • Interpretation of statutes

Facts

The respondent awarded a contract to the appellant for the construction of the Interim Measures Building and utility Services Works at the Kaduna Airport. This was embodied in a contract agreement dated 3/11/80. By a letter dated 9/6/82, the Respondent unilaterally terminated the contract for alleged poor performance in the execution of the contract. By letter dated 16/6/82, the appellant replied that the termination was a breach of contract and as a result a dispute had arisen between the parties within the meaning of clause or section 19 of the contract agreement The said clause or section 19 provides for a preliminary procedure the settlement of disputes to precede an eventual submission to arbitration within the meaning of the Arbitration Law of Lagos State.

As a result of the failure by' the parties to agree on the appointment of an arbitrator that led to the appellant filing an originating summons at the High Court where it sought the following reliefs:

  • a
    An order that respondent in this matter shall submit to arbitration in accordance with Section 19 of the General Conditions of the contract entered into between the Applicant and the Respondent on the 3rd day of January, 1980.
  • b
    An order to appoint an Arbitration to arbitrate in this matter of the contract entered into between the Applicant and the Respondent on the 3rd day of January 1980
  • c
    An order compelling the Respondent to submit to such Arbitration.
  • d
    An order directing that the Respondent do pay the cost of this application.

The application was opposed by the respondent which contended that the appellant did not satisfy the requirement or condition imposed on it by clause or section 19 of the Contract Agreement and that the appellant also failed to give the mandatory 7 days notice to the respondent before filing the application contrary to section (2) of the Arbitration Law of Lagos State.

The High Court dismissed the application agreeing that there was none-compliance with section 6(2) of the Arbitration Law. The appellant's appeal to the Court of Appeal was dismissed and it appealed further to the Supreme Court.

Issues

Whether the statutory notice to appoint or concur in the appointment of an...

Read More